Emergency Room Asthma on the Rise |
Patients Unprepared in dealing with their asthma Turn to the emergency room for survival
|
By Carlos Camargo, M.D. DrPH Department of Emergency Medicine Massachusetts General Hospital |
| ASTHMA
COMMON AND EXPENSIVE |
|
Asthma
is a common disorder that affects approximately 15 million
Americans. Although the largest effects of asthma are on quality
of life (e.g., chronic activity limitations, missed school
days, poor self-perceived health), dangerous asthma exacerbations
are quite common. In the United States, asthma exacerbations
account for 2 million emergency department visits annually,
and 500,000 hospitalizations. More than 5,500 Americans actually
die from asthma every year. These are preventable deaths.
In monetary terms, asthma costs at least $6 billion per year,
with more recent estimates from the NIH exceeding $11 billion.
Approximately 50% of the economic impact is associated with
emergency department visits, hospitalization, and death -
in other words, expenditures related to asthma exacerbations
rather than the management of chronic, stable asthma. No matter
how you describe it, the problem is big and . it's growing.
|
| RISE
IN ASTHMA PREVALENCE |
|
Over
the last 20 years, the prevalence of asthma in the US has
increased dramatically. In the early 1970s, a national survey
by the Public Health Service estimated that 3% of the US population
has asthma. The most recent figures put asthma prevalence
at somewhere between 4 to 8%. An exact estimate is not available.
If one assumes 6%, this would represent a 100% increase in
asthma prevalence over the past 25 years. If we put this in
absolute terms, that means an additional 8 to 10 million Americans
with asthma. Several studies suggest that the increase has
been greater among children than adults. For example, between
1980 and 1994, asthma increased 160% among children age 0-4
and 74% among children age 5-14. Among adults age 35-64, the
increase was 59%. The increase also has been greater among
women than men. For example, between 1980 and 1994, asthma
increased 92% among women and 60% among men. Although data
are less consistent, it appears that asthma prevalence also
may be rising more among African-Americans and Hispanics than
among whites. For decades, African Americans have had consistently
higher asthma prevalence rates than whites.
|
| POTENTIAL
CAUSES OF ASTHMA |
|
Although
some portion of the increase may be due to improved recognition
of asthma, the increases are much too large for this explanation
alone. The speed of the epidemic also argues against a genetic
explanation, though genetic tendencies toward asthma undoubtedly
play a role. Thus, the dramatic increase in asthma prevalence
is most likely due to widespread changes in behavioral and
environmental causes for asthma. Differences in asthma prevalence
(or severity) across different geographic areas provide important
clues regarding the causes of asthma, and can assist health
planners responsible for controlling the current epidemic.
For example, at a global level, many have observed that asthma
tends to be more common in developed nations, where indoor
living, lack of exposure to certain childhood infections,
sedentary living, and obesity are more common. Could these
factors be related to asthma? Similar studies also indicate
that asthma is largely an urban phenomenon. For example, more
than 20% of US asthma deaths in one year occurred in New York
City and Chicago, even though these places had only 7% of
Americans with asthma. Why? What is it about these places
that increases risk?
As
with other chronic diseases, many different factors are probably
responsible. Some of the factors that have been related to
asthma, and which require further study, include: increased
rates of prematurity (and premature infant survival), decreased
rates of breastfeeding, unfavorable changes in the outdoor
environment (e.g., air pollution), unfavorable changes in
the indoor environment (e.g., smoking, indoor allergens, irritant
gases), changes in socioeconomic status, changes in diet and
physical activity (and development of obesity), and changes
in the medical care environment (i.e.access to medical care,
pharmacotherapy). Surprisingly, in 1999, we still lack a good
understanding of how these factors relate to one another and
of their relative importance in causing asthma. Further research
is urgently needed in this arena, with particular attention
to the role of early life factors, cockroach allergen, childhood
infections, and obesity. For an American child in the inner
city, living in a run-down tenement building, spending hours
upon hours watching television, afraid to go outside due to
the fear of violence . one can easily imagine his or her dramatically
increased risk of developing asthma. The more we understand
this complex picture, the better we can identify potential
targets for intervention and assist those responsible for
designing and implementing such programs.
|
| ACUTE
ASTHMA IN THE UNITED STATES |
|
With
the exception of asthma mortality, considerably less data
are available about acute asthma - that is, asthma exacerbations
that require modification of chronic asthma management. Although
such exacerbations often can be managed by patients without
contact with doctors or the hospital system - if patients
are properly instructed - many(possibly most) asthma exacerbations
in the US continue to generate acute asthma "encounters" such
as urgent office visits, ED visits, and hospitalizations.
I
strongly encourage you to dedicate more federal funds toward
studying this problem. Specifically, we need to support researchers
who are quite eager to tackle this problem but lack the resources
to conduct the clinical research that is required. For example,
what can we do to better treat and prevent these asthma attacks?
Among patients who experience near-fatal events, what can
we do to prevent them from returning for another hospital
admission, or, even worse, dying from this very treatable
disease?
Emergency
department visits provide a window into the magnitude and
nature of the problem. In the US, emergency department visits
have climbed from 1.2 million in the late 1980s to almost
2 million this year. In response to this situation, a group
of emergency physicians formed a voluntary organization called
the Multicenter Airway Research Collaboration (or MARC). With
the assistance of a small grant from the National Heart, Lung,
and Blood Institute, and several unrestricted grants from
industry, I and my colleagues have managed to build a network
of more than 80 emergency departments across North America
that conducts research on asthma exacerbations (http://healthcare.partners.org/marc).
Preliminary
data from this collaboration reveal several important findings.
For example, more than 90% of children who present to the
emergency department with an asthma attack actually have a
primary care provider. Despite this, two-thirds go directly
to the emergency department when having problems with their
asthma and one-third rely on the emergency department for
all of their asthma medications. Since emergency physicians
are trained to manage emergencies, with little emphasis on
preventive medicine, this may explain why most of these children
are not on any preventive medications. There is a strong interest
among academic emergency physicians to better understand how
to make this cultural change, how to link better with primary
care doctors, how to approach the emergency department visit
as a "teachable moment" .. These efforts need your support.
|
| IMPLICATIONS
|
|
The
apparent overall increase in asthma morbidity and mortality,
and differential asthma burden in specific sociodemographic
groups, all have important implications for clinical care,
research, and health policy. At a patient level, the relative
lack of attention to epidemiological and clinical issues,
particularly the management of asthma exacerbations, has led
us to provide relatively unfocused therapy for a remarkably
diverse group of patients. Indeed, one might marvel at how
well current therapies work for what is, undoubtedly, a mixture
of asthma subtypes. A better understanding of the biological
and environmental causes of asthma would allow us to better
target treatments for these asthma subtypes. Identification
of the factors that have led to the current asthma epidemic
and, more specifically, to the increased burden in specific
demographic groups, also may have direct implications for
clinical care (e.g., asthma prevention in high-risk individuals).
Clearly, more research is needed in this arena. At a societal
level, current efforts to describe the US asthma burden are
sufficient to provide us with gross estimates but little more.
Asthma affects at least 5% of all Americans, is increasing,
and already exacts an enormous toll on American society -
in terms of direct health care costs, as well as missed school
and work days. The problem is of sufficient magnitude that
it merits increased attention from the health policy planners.
We can and must do something to reduce this burden of suffering.
Better
asthma surveillance data also are needed to assist effective
health policy planning, including the provision of adequate
access to health care. Numerous studies suggest that specific
groups (i.e., children, women, African Americans, and inner
city inhabitants) bear a disproportionate percentage of the
US asthma burden, and that public health efforts might be
best focused on these populations. Research is needed on the
most effective educational and interventional strategies for
each group, particularly in the emergency department where
a large number of these high-risk patients routinely seek
care.
|
| SUMMARY
|
|
There
is persuasive evidence that asthma prevalence is rising in
the US and, for that matter, worldwide. Despite numerous research
challenges, methodologically strong research can and must
be conducted to reduce the burden of asthma exacerbations
on the US health care system. The frequency of asthma exacerbations
is rising, as demonstrated by dramatic increases in the annual
number of asthma-related emergency department visits. The
distribution of asthma varies dramatically by age, sex, race,
and socioeconomic status. Although every demographic group
is affected, certain groups (i.e., children, women, African
Americans, and inner city inhabitants) appear to bear a disproportionate
percentage of the asthma burden in the US. It is difficult
to ascribe the current asthma epidemic to any single underlying
factor; however, environmental factors, such as indoor allergens
and obesity, and unequal access to medical care clearly play
major roles. Greater funding is urgently needed to study the
causes and treatments of asthma. Furthermore, we should strive
to broadly implement effective treatment and preventive measures,
promoting equal access to these benefits for all Americans.
|
|
|
|
|
Reprinted
with permission.
|
|
|
|
|
|


|
Airfree Onix 3000 Air Sterilizers
$269.00
The New Onix 3000 is totally silent and eliminates 99.99% of all micro-organisms using the new & efficient patented Airfree technology!Black. Covers up to 650 sq. ft.
|
|
|
|
|
|


|
Blueair 402 Air Purifiers
$399.95
Blueair 402 air purifier with HEPASilent filtration is good for general indoor air pollution and allergen control in rooms up to 365 sq. ft. Optional SmokeStop filters.
|
|
|
|
|
|




|
WhiteWing Steamer Vapor Steam Cleaner
$699.95 and up $599.95 and up
Best value, mid-range single tank steam cleaner. Quality construction. 285 degree boiler temp.
On Sale - Save $100 & More! Plus Free Bonus Warranty - $79.95 value!
|
|
|
|
|
|



|
Ladybug 2200S Steam Cleaner with TANCS
$1499.00
Top-of-the-line continuous fill steam cleaner with TANCS patented technology for faster cleaning and near sterilization. 290 degree boiler temp. for deep cleaning.
FREE $30 Tool Kit!
|
|
|
|
|
|


|
Ladybug 2200S Steam Cleaner with TANCS - Deluxe package
$1599.00
Portable steam cleaners use dry vapor and are great for floors, household cleaning, residential, commercial use, tile, mold, mildew, bacteria, asthma, allergies. Now available with the TANCS for advanced steam cleaning and disinfecting.
FREE $30 Tool Kit!
|
|
|
|
|
|





|
Clean Home Essentials 65 Pint Low Temperature Dehumidifiers
$349.95 $299.95
Great value and the perfect choice for those seeking a reliable, simple, and easy-to-use dehumidifier to get the job done in a basement or living room. Covers room up to 1300 sq. ft., down to 41°. Energy Star Certified.
On Sale Now! - Save $50!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|