| Allergy Consumer Review Issue #60
Editor: Mercia Tapping, President,
Allergy Buyers Club
PLEASE NOTE that references to prices or specials within this archive reflect prices
and market conditions at the time of newsletter publication.
Prices may have changed since publication. |
Dear Everyone
Isn't
the Internet wonderful? Last month I received
an email from a woman in England who had
read this newsletter, wondering if I was
the same Mercia Tapping who was her best
friend in kindergarten. This I may say was
over fifty years ago. Since then we have
exchanged emails, and it has brought a big
smile to my face going down memory lane.
When you have nearly 50 years of your life
to catch up, you have some explaining to
do. So when she said that I must be proud
of all the things I have achieved over the
years, it gave me pause for thought, as
those were not the words I would have chosen.
My father once told me
when it was clear that I was not going to
have children, that I should find some other
and perhaps unique way of contributing to
the world. I am at heart an educator, and
can never resist the opportunity to share
knowledge with others, especially if it will
make their lives better in some way. Whether
it is a good book, the movie that will make
you smile, or in the case of this newsletter,
my opinions as to what products actually work
the way they should. This is my modest way
of trying to make life better for others.
So this month, I have written
about several issues that I feel will be
of interest to many of you. Firstly, I took
a broad sweep across many of our product
categories and have pointed out those which
in my opinion offer better than usual value
for money. Also, our candid assessment of
two new air cleaners, the Electrolux
electrostatic air cleaner and the Blueair
301 air purifier, definitely fit the
bill for “quiet air cleaners for bedroom
use”. By the way, our best rated air
purifiers, the IQAir,
are going up in price by mid-March so if
you've been waiting to purchase one of these
great machines - now is the time.
 |
And
for those of you who have suffered this
winter in the Northeast, Spring is unbelievably
just around the corner. Even the thought
of it makes me happy! |
So here's to the last
of winter!
Mercia |
|
In This Issue
Shop Talk
|
|
Coming
Soon! A Special Offer on the New Exclusive
Blueair 301 Air Purifier - Two Free
Bonus Replacement Filters Included with
Your Purchase! The
new Exclusive
Blueair 301 air purifier will
be available at the end of March 2004
and will come with two bonus replacement
filters worth $90. This smaller air
cleaner is quiet and
ideal for a bedroom or small office.
Value priced at $349.95, reserve yours
today and you will receive the two
bonus filters as well. We simply love
this machine and could not recommend
it more highly and think you will
love it too.
|
Top
|
New
Product Round Up
Silk
duvet covers (starting at $229) are
simply the ultimate in luxury but most come
in sizes, which are too small. So we had
some specially made in “oversize”.
The only color right now for the oversized
duvet is “honey” in a bamboo
print, but I can tell you that I am now
spoiled for life and have fantasies of how
super silk sheets must feel. The only trouble
with silk sheets is they are not made large
enough for my deep mattresses. But once
that problem is solved, I will be first
in line.
Aquasana
shower head filters are serious! They
filter out more pollutants and have a bigger
charcoal filter than anything else we have
seen. No chlorine when you shower and will
leave your hair feeling incredibly soft
and clean. A little clunky in appearance,
and the set up takes a few minutes, but
Aquasana
shower filters at $59.95 are the same
as those being sold elsewhere under a different
label at over twice the price! My husband
is now such a fan of shower filters he insists
on having spare filters around so he can
replace them with no down time. Also Aquasana
has an excellent water
filter at $92.95 which does an effective
job at a economical price per gallon of
purified water. Did you know your coffee
tastes better when you use purified water?
We
have a whole new line of rugged Sanitaire
vacuum cleaners starting at $149.95
which are mainly for commercial use including
a backpack model which is rather intriguing.
I prefer my pocketbook in backpack format
so I am wondering whether a backpack would
appeal as a “guy’s vacuum”?
If my husband actually vacuumed (which he
does not), I could see this having a masculine
rugged appeal. No, I have not tried it out
personally, as there are limits to what
I will do at weekends in the name of product
testing!
We
also have some new natural lighting products
including Full
spectrum light boxes starting at $158.95
and Sunlight
alarm clock desk lamps beginning at
$98.95 that will be available in mid-March.
I am a great fan of full spectrum lighting
and have gradually converted over my whole
house. And when you have done it, there
is no turning back. The bathroom vanity
lights were the last in the changeover and
what natural lighting has done to showcase
my paintings is a real pleasure. I got into
full spectrum lighting when I bought a Verilux
light box about 5 years ago, which is
still going strong and I haven’t even
replaced a bulb as yet. I even use my light
box to light up my entire home office. When
you turn it off, even with spot lights on,
the room is noticeably darker.
We
have added a new organic
wool mattress pad starting at $259.95.
Besides the added softness, these pads have
the additional benefit by keeping your body
temperature on a more even keel, giving
you more warmth in the winter and cooler
in the summer. Those are some of the magical
thermal properties of wool.
Top
|
Do
You Get What You Pay For?
GREAT VALUE PRODUCTS
AND WHY SOME PRODUCTS COST MORE THAN OTHERS.
Air Purifiers: Looking
for a bargain in Air Purifiers is a challenge.
Nobody in their right mind wants to sacrifice
quality in the name of price. As one woman
put it to me “I want a 5- star air
purifier for a 3-star price”. For
a complete explanation of different air
purifier technologies refer to a previous
article on the subject “All
you wanted to know about air purifiers but
were afraid to ask”.
Here is what is happening with the air purifier
market. Air purifiers have been taken up
by the “Big Box” companies and
low cost ones are now manufactured in China.
Many of them are pretty worthless in terms
of performance and can be found oversold
by all sorts of disreputable companies.
A surprising exception is the Hamilton
Beach series which we tested and found
to be very efficient, and reasonably quiet
The only drawback as they only do small
spaces and cannot cope with odors and gases
in an effective manner. But apart from that,
they are an excellent deal and are now on
sale starting at $99.95.
Most
of the very high performance air purifiers
are manufactured by European or by smaller
specialty manufacturers. The quality is
often superb but the cost of manufacturing
is higher. The IQAir
series is a case in point, offering
superb efficiency and cleaning power second
to none but you pay for the privilege. If
you need both allergen and odor and gas
control, I often tell people that the Austin
Air beginning at $250 is an honest workhorse
even if it is completely devoid of all the
whistles and bells I prefer to see on a
air purifier, like easy changing filters
and replacement alerts. Later in this newsletter
we review the new Blueair
301, an AllergyBuyersClub.com exclusive,
and a very cost effective choice for a quiet
air cleaner in a small (12x12) bedroom at
$349.95. The Electrolux
air cleaner (shown right) at $499.95
is also quiet and offers a good amount of
efficient cleaning and low cost maintenance.
Dehumidifiers: The
industry dirty little secret about low cost
dehumidifiers, is they break down soon as
you look at them. I sat down with one US
manufacturer the other day and he was telling
us which of their machines were still made
in the USA as opposed to Asia and admitted
that the Asian ones reduced manufacturing
costs but did not improve quality. I found
this news somewhat dispiriting. So far we
have had the best luck with Comfort-aire
dehumidifiers beginning at $319.95 and
yes they come from China but the return
rate for defects last year was incredibly
low, although the low temp models are loud.
Since they have changed factories this year,
I am holding my breath that the new factory
will be as reliable. So bargain pickings
here are pretty slim until you pay for either
an Ebac
(starting at $529.95) or the Santa
Fe ($1429.95) dehumidifiers. Both Ebac
and Santa Fe offer dehumidifiers that last
for years and years and do a superior job
and are quieter to boot.
Humidifiers:
When all is said and done, I am starting
to get convinced that the cheapest is also
the best. This would be the Hamilton
Beach, a brand of humidifiers (beginning
at $49.95 -shown right) we rarely see returned
to us. On the other hand, some of the Hunter
humidifiers this year seem to be much
noisier than I ever remembered and I am
wondering whether they have a new source
in Asia that is not producing the same quality
as before. This is only a hunch and certainly
not confirmed by Hunter. So the inexpensive
Hamilton Beach is certainly simple to maintain,
and on “quiet mode” my husband
is happy to have it in our bedroom and it
hugely reduces his snoring.
Shower Filters: One
of our new shower filters, the Aquasana
at $59.95, is the best deal here as we found
the exact same shower filter under a different
label on a competitor’s site for nearly
3 times the price. This shower head filter
has a huge amount of filter media which
makes it inelegant to look at but my husband
who tests out shower filters in our house
voted it a winner.
Steam Cleaners: Here the clear winner
for value for money is the WhiteWing
vapor steamer which offers a lot of
functionality for the price of $399.95.
Another way of putting it, is it suits most
of the people most of the time. This is
to say, that most people use steam cleaners
intermittently and for short burst type
of tasks such as when my husband lovingly
cleans his golf clubs or I get inspired
to clean some neglected nook and cranny
in my house. The “clean freaks”
are better off with the more expensive models
such as the Ladybug,
which will clean for hours on end without
interruption and to a cleaning maven’s
high standards (prices start at $1199.95).
Vacuum
Cleaners. This is a tough call as to
which are the best values since one has
to balance both functionality and durability,
and the latter is often not visible until
years later. Most people tell us that they
are fed up with their vacuum cleaner breaking
down every two years and needing to replace
it. Overall, if I had to pick a brand that
offers incredible durability and a feature
packed hepa vacuum, I would opt for any
of the SEBO
vacuums as they are mid priced starting
at $399. I would also buy one now before
the inevitable price increase I smell on
the horizon. For a true bargain, the Eureka
model 6984 for homes with carpets at
$299 plus a bonus washable hepa filter is
tough to beat. What’s more, we have
sold it for a couple of years now and we
never see them sent back here so I am reasonably
confident about the quality. The new Electrolux
Harmony for bare floors at $399.99 is
worth mentioning because it is the first
Electrolux vacuum out at this kind of price
range and our staff are really quite entranced
with it. Will it hold up over time? Well,
the jury is still out on that one. And if
you are on the other end of the Spectrum
and just want the “very best money
can buy”, then you would opt for the
Miele
Velvet vacuum priced at $1249.
Bedding.
Our selection of bedding is vast but here
is where quality can catch up with you pretty
fast. For instance, in pillows
the Primaloft are inexpensive starting at
$74.95 for a set of two and are soft when
you first purchase them but be prepared
to dump them after 18 months when they compress
and turn lumpy. We have 3-month old and
18-month old Primaloft
pillows on our bed and the difference
between them is astonishing. On the other
hand, the more expensive Hypodown
pillows beginning at $99.95 are like
the Energizer Bunny and keep going and going.
The same caveats apply to the Primaloft
comforters starting at $119.95 but you
can prolong their lives by always using
a duvet
cover but they only have a fraction
of the warmth of a down comforter. The best
kept secret value for the money in comforters
is the Euphoria
wool comforters beginning at $279.95
which are amazingly light in weight while
providing breathability and warmth, and
the silk comforters, the Imperial
Delight and Ming
Dynasty, which are cloud light and completely
luxurious for summer months (prices begin
at $199.95 for these silk comforters). I
have been trying out bargain brands of high
thread count sheets recently (a tough job
but someone has to do it!) in an effort
to find something really well priced to
offer our customers.
Here is what I have found. Inexpensive sheet
sets skimp on sizing, so if you have a mattress
pad, a deeper mattress or a pillow larger
than child’s size, the sheets do not
fit. The Diva
400 thread count 100% cotton sateen sheets
are fairly priced (starting at $99.95) and
are amply oversized to fit deep mattresses.
Top
|
New
Exclusive Blueair 301 Air Purifier
-Sneak Preview
(2/26/04) We
pleaded with Blueair to put out a pintsized
version of their big Blueair
501 air purifier, so we really had something
nice to offer our Blueair customers who
wanted a second air purifier for their office
or child’s bedroom. As soon as we
saw the sample Blueair
301, our staff were oohing and ahhing
with comments like “oh, so cute!".
We chose Blueair because in our experience
with these machines, although their efficiency
is not perfect, they are beautifully quiet,
easy to take care off with filter changes
taking all of 30 seconds, and we never see
them returned to us. So we have ended up
with an exclusive for our subscribers and
web visitors, which is a super deal at the
price of $349.95 includes two replacement
filters, three filters in all. This is something
to really consider! In a particle count
efficiency test that we performed with the
Blueair 301, the results were 86.4% on low,
88.6% on medium, 73.8% on high, and an average
cleaning efficiency of 84.7%. This means
that on average, 84.7% of the particles
going into the machine were captured by
the filter. This would be on all particulates
0.3 microns and larger. Providing the filters
are changed regularly, there is no drop
in efficiency and the results are acceptable.
Although these results are not as high as
with our best high end Hepa air cleaners,
they are acceptable as 4 to 6 or more air
changes are achieved. We have a more extensive
review of the Blueair
301 on our web site but the bottom line
is if you have a room of this size- yes
you want one! I have two larger 501
Blueair air purifiers in our house and
I am a great fan of them.
Top
|
| Electrolux
Air Purifier
We
were looking for an alternative to the Friedrich
electrostatic air purifiers, for those who
resolutely want to avoid some of the expense
of replacing hepa filters. We were surprisingly
pleased with the results of our testing
of the Electrolux
air purifiers, which are not without
their drawbacks as noted below in a report
by David Barnaby. When David says he likes
a product, I listen, as he is worse than
I am in giving products the thumbs down.
My big grumble is that since Electrolux
is owned by Eureka, they COULD have chosen
to put into the machine their exclusive
washable hepa filter which they use with
their vacuum cleaners. But they did not
and I intend to bring that up to them as
a product improvement.The Electrolux air
cleaner test results did not disappoint.
David tested this air purifier over a 40-day
period. With new filters, the particle count
efficiency was 99.3% on speed 1; 93.2 for
speed 2; 75.6 on speed 3. The average particle
count efficiency is 89.4%.
The air cleaner was re-tested on day 40
for efficiency and the results were encouraging:
99.0% on speed 1; 93.8% on speed 2; and
66.1% on speed 3. The average particle count
efficiency was 86.3% after running the unit
for 40 days. The only noticeable reduction
of efficiency was a 12.6% decrease on speed
3. The following is a summary of what David,
who leads our product testing team, had
to say about the Electrolux air cleaner.
Pluses:
- Has built-in indicator
lights: Reminds owner that the filters
need to be cleaned or replaced
- Air cleaner is quiet:
Almost silent on low speed, quiet on medium
speed and noticeably louder on high speed
but not as noisy as other units on high.
- Easy access: for
cleaning or replacing filters
- Quiet fan setting:
This mode regulates the speed of the fan
based upon the noise in the room; the
fan will speed up when the sensor detects
noise in the room, and slow down when
it is quiet to not disturb the peace.
- Contains an air quality
sensor: Allows the air cleaner to
adjust the speeds based upon the contaminate
level in the room
- Spare parts included:
An additional corona wire is included
- Lightweight: Makes
this air cleaner easy to carry
- Attractive exterior:
Electrolux gave this air cleaner modern
styling with a titanium gray color and
a chrome knob that can blend into any
environment, and kept the unit value-priced
- Efficient air
filtration: Overall, this unit is
a very efficient air cleaner considering
that it is not a true HEPA-type air cleaner.
- Odor free:
There was no discernable evidence of an
ozone smell
Minuses:
- The accompanying air cleaner manual
is not easy to understand
- Pre-filters will collect only very
large-sized particles but it is a nice
feature to have a pre-filter in an electrostatic
air cleaner
- The electrostatic filter has an odor
when new but the smell dissipated after
running the air cleaner constantly on
high for a few days
- The unit is considered high maintenance
since an owner will have to:
- clean the filters regularly (every
two months or when indicator light is
displayed)
- replace the carbon pre-filter every
three - six months, however it is okay
to run the unit without this filter
if not needed
- replace the electrostatic filter once
a year depending upon how frequently
the unit is used
- This unit is not recommended for removal
of high concentration of gases and odors
since there is only a small amount of
carbon in the filter
- Not recommended for those with multiple
chemical sensitivities
Summary:
The Electrolux
air cleaner is value priced at $499.95
for the highly efficient air filtration
that it provides. It is lightweight, attractive,
and has user-friendly indicator lights to
take the guesswork out of when to replace
or clean the air cleaner, which is greatly
appreciated.
Top
|
Sinus
Irrigator For Our Subscribers
Dr Grossan's Hydro-Pulse
Nasal Irrigator for sinus sufferers is
now available at AllergyBuyersClub.com!
Top
|
Sinusitis
in Children
Prevent Children's
Sinusitis Month
By Murray Grossan
MD This
month, the American Academy of Otolaryngology
– (ear nose and throat) in conjunction
with the American Academy of Allergy is
urging parents to take steps to prevent
their kids from growing up with chronic
sinusitis. Children are born with sinus
cavities and they can be infected at any
age. Often sinus problems start in childhood.
Number one cause may be the child blowing
the nose too hard. Parents are urged to
teach their kids: Blow the nose GENTLY or
not at all. Heavy blowing spreads the bacteria
to uninfected areas including the ears and
irritates the delicate nasal membranes so
they can’t function to protect against
disease. Here are 12 rules to teach the
kids to avoid them growing up as a sinus
patient – rules from the Tower ENT
Group at Cedar Sinai Medical in Los Angeles.
1. If you see a green drainage
from one side of the nose only, think of
a foreign body – a raisin or a nut.
Best to have this removed by an ENT specialist.
2. Insist your child blow his / her nose
gently.
3. Follow your doctor’s instructions
regarding medications. Never stop the antibiotic
before the recommended dose. This is how
we develop drug resistant bacteria.
4. Make sure your child is up on his immunizations.
5. Try to avoid the child getting chilled.
6. Don’t overheat the bedrooms.
7. Child’s bedroom should preferably
be as bare as possible. No moth flakes,
insecticides, or dust makers.
8. Pets should be kept out of the bedroom
as well as out of the bed.
9. Moisturize the bedroom in cold or dry
weather. Best method is to use pans of water
for evaporation.
10. Avoid nasal sprays with Benzalkonium
or Thimerosal as these may irritate the
nose.
11. Avoid smoke in the child’s presence
12. If there is considerable dust, use a
Hepa filter (not an ionizer)
There are some common sense
steps to prevent a life of sinus misery
for your child. It is very important to
keep the moisture at no more than 50%. If
the moisture goes above 50% this encourages
mold growth. Check for leaks that may grow
mold. A regular light bulb turned on in
a damp closet or basement is a mold deterrent.
Yellow green drainage that persists for
more than a week suggests a sinus infection.
Three of these episodes per year suggests
a chronic sinus infection. If your very
young child has a persistent nasal / sinus
infection, ask your doctor about performing
Proetz sinus irrigation. This is an inexpensive
treatment parents can do at home. Here the
child is placed with his head lowered and
dilute nose drops are placed in one nostril
and suctioned from the other with a simple
nasal aspirator till all the colored pus
is removed. (complete directions can be
obtained from The Sinus Cure by Debra Bruce
and Murray Grossan page 120. For the child
5 or older who has persistent sinus drainage,
ask your doctor about using pulsatile irrigation
to remove the pus and thick mucus to allow
the natural healing to take place. Units
such as the Hydro Pulse Nasal / Sinus irrigator
are gentle enough for kids to use age 5
or older, and most kids (and adults) appreciate
the relief they get. Because the pressure
is regulated exactly right, it is much safer
than sniffing from the hand or unregulated
pots and syringes where the pressure can
be too high.
Is it allergy? It is very
important to follow your pediatrician’s
instructions regarding the age at which
foods are started. This helps avoid allergies.
Your doctor’s advice for breast feeding
is also an allergy preventer. If your child
is sneezing, eyes look puffy, but he is
free of fever or fatigue, note the date
on your calendar. Often you can tell what
the allergy is due to by using the pollen
calendars available on the net.
Your doctor may recommend
one of the cortisone sprays. At this time
these nasal sprays have been in use for
decades and are now felt to be safe for
kids to use. Of course, any medication is
best not taken if it isn’t necessary.
Morning sneezing? Usually this is an effort
of the allergic child to get warm. Prevent
this by having warm tea in bed before getting
out of bed. Usually a thermos does well.
If the child has asthma, it
is even more critical to prevent and clear
sinus problems.
Does your child have sinusitis
or enlarged adenoids? Adenoids are the tonsil
like tissue in back of the nose. With sinus
infection they may enlarge and block nasal
breathing. Or they may enlarge on their
own usually accompanied by enlarged tonsils.
Before you rush to have surgery for this
condition, ask your doctor about measures
to shrink the adenoids. Clearing a sinus
condition is the first step in getting adenoids
back to normal size. Other methods include
anti-inflammatory medications, often combined
with antibiotics.Your doctor may recommend
fruit enzymes for this, Papain from papaya
or Bromelain from pineapple, such as the
product Clearease™.
One reason the Allergy and
ENT groups want to call attention to sinus
and other childhood ailments is so that
the parents can appreciate that a child
who is constantly mouth breathing and is
snoring, is not a healthy child. He / she
may not sleep well, have bad breath, and
be constantly fatigued, cranky, or run down.
Such a child deserves care so they can grow
up and not be one of the 35 million persons
who now have sinusits. Despite the daily
barrage of advertisements, the best thing
for your child’s cold is still chicken
soup, tea with lemon - honey, and bed rest.
For best information, consult your doctor.
http://www.hydromedonline.com/
Top |
Regards,
Mercia Tapping,
President
|
|
|
|